The published factors say gas is 15% worse. Delivered as heat it is 2–3.5×.
A published energy factor is per kWh of fuel. A process needs heat at the ware. Between them sits the equipment — and for a kiln, that is 66–82% of the real difference between gas and electricity.
5 min read · last checked
Compare the published factors for natural gas and UK grid electricity and gas looks marginally worse — 0.213 against 0.184 kg CO₂e per kWh, all terms counted. A 15% gap. On that arithmetic, switching a gas oven to an electric one is a rounding error and not worth the capital.
That arithmetic is comparing the wrong things. A published energy factor is per kWh of fuel. A process does not need fuel; it needs heat at the ware. Between those two sits the equipment, and that is where almost all of the difference lives.
| Basis | Gas | Grid electricity |
|---|---|---|
| Per kWh bought | 0.2125 | 0.1844 |
| Efficiency into the ware, kiln | 30–60% | 92–99% |
| Per kWh of HEAT DELIVERED | 0.354–0.708 | 0.186–0.200 |
kg CO₂e per kWh. Divide by the efficiency, don't multiply — you always need more fuel than duty, never less.
Gas is 1.15× electricity on the tables and 1.9× to 3.5× per kilowatt-hour of heat that actually reaches the product. The published comparison understates the real one by between a factor of two and a factor of three.
Most of the gap is the equipment, not the fuel
This is the part worth separating, because the two halves have completely different price tags. Some of the difference is which carrier you buy — a procurement decision, available this quarter. The rest is how efficiently your equipment turns that carrier into heat — a capital decision, available when the furnace is replaced.
| Equipment | Gas per useful kWh | Electric | Ratio | Of the gap, equipment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kiln, worst case (30%) | 0.708 | 0.200 | 3.54× | 82% |
| Kiln, best case (60%) | 0.354 | 0.186 | 1.90× | 72% |
| Gas oven (45%) | 0.472 | 0.200 | 2.36× | 77% |
| Gas oven, well run (70%) | 0.304 | 0.186 | 1.63× | 66% |
Two thirds to four fifths of the real difference is the flue, not the fuel.
A flue-fired kiln throws away between 40% and 70% of what it burns. A resistance element puts essentially all of it into the load, because there is no flue. That is the whole mechanism, and it is why the honest headline on electrification is not “cleaner electricity” — the grid factor barely matters here — but “you stop heating the sky”.
Which means the cheap lever and the expensive one are not the same lever
If 78% of the gap on your kiln is equipment, switching tariff or carrier buys you the other 22% and no more. Conversely, recuperation on the existing kiln — moving from the bottom of that 30–60% band towards the top — halves the gas route’s intensity without changing anything you buy.
Every process on this site that carries a heat duty states both efficiency bands for exactly this reason: kiln firing at 30–60% fuel-fired against 92–99% electric, drying and curing likewise. A process with no electric route stated is one where the library has no basis to offer the lever, and it is left out rather than guessed at.
The caveat that makes this honest
Two of them. First, which electricity figure you use changes the answer: the calculation above is location-based, and a market-based renewable tariff would make the electric route look better still — for contractual rather than physical reasons.
Second, the grid figure moves and gas does not. UK grid intensity has fallen for a decade and will keep falling; the carbon in a therm of methane is fixed by chemistry. An electrification case that is marginal today gets better on its own, and a gas case never does.
Check it yourself
Every figure above is on this site with its source, geography, method and licence.
Also worth knowing
- Why two published carbon factors for the same material disagree
- A 70% scrap rate does not cost you 70% more material
- The energy factor you quoted is missing about a third of itself
- Your renewable tariff is zero and 0.131 at the same time
- The same steel is 1.99 and 1.14 kg CO₂e, and both are correct
- Some of a kiln's CO₂ comes out of the rock, not the flame
- When cutting carbon makes something else worse
Use this
These are the mistakes the assessment engine is built to avoid making. To watch it not make them on a product of your own, run a bill of materials through the free carbon calculator — no sign-up, and it runs in your browser. For the whole picture, including the process and its scrap, model the whole route in the prototype, or see what TrueGauge does for a manufacturer.
Early access
Request early access.
Both products are pre-launch. We're working with an early group of manufacturers, architects, builders and sustainability teams to shape what gets built first — tell us which platform is relevant to you.
Shape the roadmap
Tell us which decisions you need supported, and what the data has to do to be usable.
First access
Be first in line as each platform opens to early users.
A direct line to the team
Early conversations happen with the people building it, not a sales funnel.