Skip to content
PunarGen

The same steel is 1.99 and 1.14 kg CO₂e, and both are correct

One steel product. Cut-off allocation says 1.99 kg CO₂e/kg; end-of-life says 1.14. A 75% spread, and nothing about the steel differs between them. The gap is the convention — and it is almost never quoted alongside the number.

6 min read · last checked

Take one steel product. 30% recycled content going in, 85% recycled at the end of its life. Ask what its cradle-to-gate footprint is and there are three defensible answers, all from the same formula, all from the same physical steel:

kg CO₂e/kgConventionAlso called
1.99Recycled content (A = 1)cut-off, 100:0
1.56Split (A = 0.5)50:50
1.14End of life (A = 0)avoided burden, 0:100

A 75% spread. Nothing about the steel differs between these three numbers.

The difference between 1.99 and 1.14 is the accounting convention, not the material. A figure quoted without its convention cannot be compared with anything — and the end-of-life convention is the one that flatters.

These are not two methods. They are one formula read at its ends.

The Circular Footprint Formula, from the European Commission’s Product Environmental Footprint method and carried into EN 15804+A2, contains a single parameter A that dials between them. Reading the formula at each end is the clearest statement of what each convention actually means:

A = 1. The recycled-input term becomes the real cost of recycling the material you consumed, and the end-of-life term vanishes entirely. Buying recycled input is rewarded; sending your product to be recycled earns you nothing.

A = 0.Recycled input is priced as though it were virgin — so buying it earns nothing — and the end-of-life term appears in full, crediting you for the virgin material your scrap will displace after the product’s life.

Every value between is also in use. The PEF assigns Aper material from the balance of supply and demand in that recyclate market, and 0.5 is the split-the-difference default. So the question is never “which method is right” — it is “which end of one formula is this figure quoted at”.

Why the choice is not neutral for you specifically

The two conventions reward opposite behaviours, which is why suppliers and buyers tend to prefer different ones without anybody being dishonest:

What you didA = 1 (cut-off)A = 0 (end of life)
Bought recycled inputrewardedworth nothing
Designed for recyclabilityworth nothingrewarded
Tends to be preferred bya buyer specifying recycled contenta producer of a recyclable material

If your customer specifies recycled content and your figure is quoted at A = 0, you are being paid for something your own number does not count. If you sell a highly recyclable material and quote at A = 1, you are giving away your best argument. Neither is a mistake in the arithmetic; both are a mismatch between the convention and the conversation.

The quietest assumption in the formula

Two parameters — the quality of secondary material against the primary it replaces, in and out — are set to 1 almost universally. That asserts recycled material substitutes one-for-one. It is true for steel and aluminium, which is why those two dominate every worked example including this one. It is false for most polymers, where each loop shortens the chains, and false for concrete crushed to aggregate, which no longer does the job the concrete did.

It always flatters recycling, and it is almost never stated. If you are reading a recycled-content claim on a polymer, that assumption is doing work nobody has shown you.

What to do

Quote the convention with the number, every time — the way the factor library states the method and boundary beside every figure it carries, and for the same reason. And when you are handed a figure, ask which end it came from before you compare it with yours.

The failure this prevents is subtle and common: two suppliers quote 1.99 and 1.14 for identical steel, the buyer picks the second, and the only thing that was actually procured is a different accounting convention. That is the same shape as two published factors disagreeing because one includes forming — a difference in the question, read as a difference in the answer.

Check it yourself

Every figure above is on this site with its source, geography, method and licence.

Use this

These are the mistakes the assessment engine is built to avoid making. To watch it not make them on a product of your own, run a bill of materials through the free carbon calculator — no sign-up, and it runs in your browser. For the whole picture, including the process and its scrap, model the whole route in the prototype, or see what TrueGauge does for a manufacturer.

Early access

Request early access.

Both products are pre-launch. We're working with an early group of manufacturers, architects, builders and sustainability teams to shape what gets built first — tell us which platform is relevant to you.

  • Shape the roadmap

    Tell us which decisions you need supported, and what the data has to do to be usable.

  • First access

    Be first in line as each platform opens to early users.

  • A direct line to the team

    Early conversations happen with the people building it, not a sales funnel.

Register interest

Which platform? *

This registers interest in early access — both platforms are pre-launch, so this isn't a product signup or a purchase.