Skip to content
PunarGen

Some of a kiln's CO₂ comes out of the rock, not the flame

Put a lime kiln on a zero-carbon tariff and a large part of its CO₂ does not move. It is not coming from the flame — it is coming out of the rock, at 0.4397 kg per kg of limestone, fixed by molar mass.

5 min read · last checked

Put a lime kiln on a zero-carbon tariff, replace the burner with green hydrogen, run the whole site on certified renewables. A substantial part of that kiln’s CO₂ does not move at all.

It is not coming from the flame. It is coming out of the rock.

CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂. Per kilogram of limestone decomposed, 44.01/100.09 = 0.4397 kg of CO₂ is released by the chemistry itself. It is stoichiometry, not combustion, and no change of fuel touches it.

The arithmetic, and why it is a floor rather than an estimate

Molar masses are not a modelling choice. CaCO₃ is 100.09 g/mol, CO₂ is 44.01, CaO is 56.08. Decompose a kilogram of limestone and you get 0.7844 kg of lime and 0.4397 kg of CO₂, every time, in every kiln that has ever been built or ever will be. Quoted per kilogram of lime produced rather than limestone consumed, it is 0.785.

kg CO₂PerFixed by
0.4397kg of CaCO₃ decomposed44.01 / 100.09
0.785kg of CaO produced44.01 / 56.08

No efficiency, tariff, fuel or technology changes either number.

The reaction also needs energy — about 1.78 MJ per kg of CaCO₃ — and in a kiln running at 30–60% efficiency that is 3.0 to 5.9 MJ of fuel. That part is addressable: recuperation, fuel switching, a different carrier entirely. The 0.4397 is not.

Why this is stored separately rather than folded into the energy

It would be simpler to add the calcination CO₂ into the kiln’s per-kilogram figure and quote one number. This site deliberately does not, and the reason is what happens when somebody then models a renewable tariff.

Fold the two together and the whole figure scales with the energy: switch to zero-carbon electricity and the model obediently reports that the chemistry stopped happening. That is not a rounding error, it is a wrong answer to the most important question anybody will ask about a kiln — and it is an easy one to produce, because the arithmetic looks perfectly reasonable right up until you notice what it claims.

So kiln firing carries the coefficient as its own term, the engine reports it as an irreducible share, and a renewable tariff cannot appear to erase it.

Stored per kg of reacting basis, not per kg of throughput

One more choice worth explaining, because it is the difference between a useful figure and a false one. How much carbonate is in the body is a property of the body, not the kiln. A lime kiln is near 100% carbonate; a porcelain kiln is near zero.

Store a flat per-kilogram-of-throughput figure on the process and you assert that every kiln calcines, which is false for most of them. The coefficient is therefore held per kilogram of reacting basis and defaults to zero of the body — so a potter gets nothing added and a lime producer gets the full term, from the same model, without either having to argue with it.

Where else this bites

Cement is the case everyone knows — clinker is around 60% CaO, and process emissions are roughly 60% of clinker’s footprint before any fuel is burned. It is why cement decarbonisation is a story about capture, clinker substitution and different binder chemistries rather than about cleaner kilns, and why a cement supplier quoting a renewable-energy commitment has told you about the smaller half.

Glass is the quieter one: soda ash and limestone in the batch release carbonate CO₂ on melting, independently of how the furnace is fired. Any process where a carbonate, sulphate or hydrate is thermally decomposed has a floor of this kind, and the general test is simple — if the reaction liberates gas from the feedstock, changing the fuel cannot reach it.

Check it yourself

Every figure above is on this site with its source, geography, method and licence.

Use this

These are the mistakes the assessment engine is built to avoid making. To watch it not make them on a product of your own, run a bill of materials through the free carbon calculator — no sign-up, and it runs in your browser. For the whole picture, including the process and its scrap, model the whole route in the prototype, or see what TrueGauge does for a manufacturer.

Early access

Request early access.

Both products are pre-launch. We're working with an early group of manufacturers, architects, builders and sustainability teams to shape what gets built first — tell us which platform is relevant to you.

  • Shape the roadmap

    Tell us which decisions you need supported, and what the data has to do to be usable.

  • First access

    Be first in line as each platform opens to early users.

  • A direct line to the team

    Early conversations happen with the people building it, not a sales funnel.

Register interest

Which platform? *

This registers interest in early access — both platforms are pre-launch, so this isn't a product signup or a purchase.