3 documents you can hand to a client and 3 screens you work in. Two of them refuse to issue under conditions they state — which is the promise being made about every figure they do produce.
Concept-stage carbon statement
PDFThe concept assessment as a document somebody else can read without the interface around it. Coverage comes before the range, because a reader who takes one figure away should take away the qualified one.
For: The Stage 2 → Stage 3 handover, and the project director who will read one paragraph of it
- Coverage — what share of the schedule carries a figure, stated first
- The range, in kgCO₂e/m² and in tonnes, against the target and its declared module scope
- Biogenic carbon reported separately, never netted into the total
- The breakdown by NRM element, largest first
- Constraints already closed by regulation, where the project is a higher-risk building
- The asks, ordered by how much of the schedule each one would bring in
- Basis and limits — including that the ranges cover A1–A3 only
Refuses: Will not issue without a schedule, or without a floor area. Every figure in it is per square metre, and issuing against a stand-in denominator would put a wrong number into the one artefact whose purpose is to be handed to somebody else.
Material selection record
PDFWhy these materials and not the others. Exclusions come first, because the sentence that changes what gets specified is “this is not permitted here”, not a score.
For: The client, the design team record, and whoever asks in two years why this was specified
- Excluded before scoring — each with the rule, the requirement, the evidence and the citation
- In contention — the materials nothing beats outright, deliberately not numbered
- Per axis: the score, the confidence, the rationale, the data points and the sources behind it
- Supplier intelligence per material, with CBAM exposure and carbon-adjusted cost
- Beaten outright — the one ordering in the document that needs no judgement
Refuses: Prints no position numbers against the materials in contention. Where each option beats the others on something, any order encodes a preference, and a “1.” is read as a verdict however carefully the surrounding text is worded.
Single-material report
PDFThe same record narrowed to one material — including one the gates removed, because “why can’t I use this?” is a fair question whose answer is worth exporting.
For: The specifier defending one choice, or querying one refusal
- For a permitted material: every axis with its evidence, and its supplier options
- For an excluded one: the rule, the requirement, what this material's evidence showed, and the instrument it rests on
Concept assessment
On screenThe live version of the statement, with the asks answerable in place — supply a density and the coverage rises and the range narrows as you watch.
For: The architect, while the build-ups can still change
- The range and the coverage, with the verdict against the target
- The element breakdown, by share
- The density asks, grouped so six lines blocked on one figure are one question
- Lines naming a material the library does not recognise, with the classes it does
Refuses: Holds the whole assessment back until there is a floor area, rather than computing it against a stand-in.
Evidence standing
On screenWhich of this project's materials loses its evidence before anyone audits the building — the check nobody runs, because nothing in the industry sends a reminder.
For: Whoever will be asked, at handover, to show the figures still hold
- Every EPD judged against the project's completion date, not today
- Expired, expiring within three months, and never issued — counted separately, because they call for different actions
- Per-axis coverage: how many materials carry what each axis claims to assess
Refuses: Runs no check at all without a completion date. Defaulting to today would pass every declaration that is current now and expires before handover — precisely the set this exists to find.
Procurement leakage
On screenDesign intent against what was actually bought, with the drift quantified — the part of a project's carbon that no design-stage report can see.
For: The team that has to explain the gap between the design and the building
- Carbon, cost and compliance drift per substitution
- Completeness stated on every total, computed by the impact engine shared with TrueGauge