A Stage 2 assessment, worked end to end
An 8,200 m² residential scheme, flagged as a higher-risk building. The schedule below is the only input. Everything under it is output — including the fact that this assessment declines to give a verdict against the target, which is the correct answer for a schedule most of whose lines cannot yet be quantified.
The input
Mixed units, build-ups written as prose, and one line naming something the library has never heard of — the shape a real schedule has. Two densities were supplied by the architect: 2,400 kg/m³ for concrete and 480 kg/m³ for CLT. The CLT one is used to quantify the biogenic storage below; the line itself stays out of the netted total, for the reason given there.
Element,Description,Quantity,Unit Substructure,Reinforced concrete raft foundation,890,m3 Superstructure,CLT frame and floor plates,1240,m3 Superstructure,Structural steel beams and columns,410,t Envelope,Brick slip rainscreen on mineral wool,3100,m2 Envelope,Aluminium curtain walling,720,m2 Envelope,PIR insulation board to roof,1900,m2 Internal finishes,Plasterboard partitions on steel studs,4400,m2 Fit-out,Bespoke reception feature,12,nr
8 schedule lines read, 1 naming no material this library recognises — those need a word it knows before they can be counted. 2 describe a build-up with more than one material; the split between them is a design decision, so it is asked for rather than assumed.
Covers 25% of the schedule — 2 of 8 lines
97–260kgCO₂e/m²
799.1 t – 2,132 t CO₂e over 8,200 m² GIA, against RIBA 2030 Climate Challenge — domestic at 300 kgCO₂e/m² (A1–A5, kgCO2e/m² GIA)
No verdict against RIBA 2030 Climate Challenge — domestic is available yet. What has been counted — 25% of the schedule — sits below it, and that is not the same as meeting it. Lines still missing a figure can only add to the total. These ranges cover modules A1-A3 and RIBA 2030 Climate Challenge — domestic is written over A1–A5, kgCO2e/m² GIA; the transport and construction left out are in the target and can only add. Everything omitted pushes the same way, so a floor cannot demonstrate a ceiling. The asks below are ordered by how much of the schedule each closes.
2 of 8 schedule lines carry a figure — 25% of the schedule. 6 lines need something before they can be counted, and each one says what. Until they are, every total below is an under-count of a known size rather than an estimate of an unknown one. What has been counted sits below RIBA 2030 Climate Challenge — domestic at 300 kgCO2e/m², and that is not the same as meeting it. The lines above that carry no figure can only add to the total. The benchmarks behind these ranges cover A1-A3, and RIBA 2030 Climate Challenge — domestic is written over A1–A5, kgCO2e/m² GIA — the transport and construction this figure omits are in the target and can only add. Everything omitted pushes one way, so no verdict against the target is available: a floor cannot demonstrate a ceiling. 1 line store biogenic carbon (875 to 1010 t CO2e of uptake). That is reported on its own and is not netted into anything above: the release that balances it falls in modules C3/C4, outside these A1-A3 benchmarks, so subtracting it here would credit storage the target does not anticipate.
Biogenic carbon — reported, not deducted
The schedule stores 875 to 1,010 t CO2e of biogenic carbon across 1 line. It is reported here and deliberately NOT subtracted from the figures above: these benchmarks cover A1-A3, the release that balances that uptake falls in modules C3/C4, and netting an unbalanced credit into a cradle-to-completion total is how a timber scheme comes to be described as near-zero.
Where it sits
By design element, ordered by size. Shares are of the covered total at its high end. This is not the NRM breakdown — that is below, and gives different totals for two of these names.
- Superstructure681 t – 1,916.9 t · 90%
- Substructure118.1 t – 215.1 t · 10%
On the NRM elemental structure
The same carbon, grouped the way a cost plan groups cost, so the two can be argued about in one conversation. NRM is a classification here and nothing more — no rate, price or £/m² is produced anywhere in this product.
Carbon allocated across 2 NRM groups, with 0% unallocated. Each group total is a floor: unallocated lines can only move into a group, never out of one.
| Element | kgCO₂e | kgCO₂e/m² | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Substructure | 118,095–215,059 | 26 | 10% |
| 2 Superstructure | 680,985–1,916,926 | 234 | 90% |
Every group total is a floor. Lines in the residual can only move into a group, never out of one, so a group total that already exceeds an elemental allowance has genuinely exceeded it — while one sitting under an allowance has proven nothing until the residual is cleared.
Module A4 — transport to site
The assessment above is A1-A3. A4 is the next module a RICS assessment and a GLA submission both ask for, and it needs one thing this product cannot know: how far the material travels. State a route and it is computed — as a band, across the published spread of the freight factors themselves.
These distances are yours. They are starting points named for a supply decision, not figures this product stands behind — change them to what your project expects.
Moving 410 tonnes 300 km by road emits 7,417 to 66,421 kgCO₂e — 0.9 to 8.1 kgCO₂e/m². The distance is yours, not this product's, and the band is the published spread of the freight factors themselves. 1 counted line carries no mass and is absent from this figure, so A4 covers 50% of what the headline total covers — a lower share than the headline's own coverage, and the two should not be read as the same number.
A4 alone
7.4 t – 66.4 t
0.9–8.1 kgCO₂e/m²
A4 at the average factor
12.7 t
1.6 kgCO₂e/m²
A1-A4 together
806.5 t – 2,198.4 t
98–268 kgCO₂e/m²
The band is not uncertainty about your route — it is the published spread of the freight factors for the modes you chose. DESNZ gives road freight from 0.060 kg CO₂e per tonne-kilometre for a fully laden articulated lorry to 0.540 for an average-laden small rigid, a factor of nine, and a specifier taking full loads on trunk routes is not doing what one taking part loads in a small rigid is doing. Collapsing that to the average would give a confident figure whose error is larger than most of the design decisions this assessment exists to inform.
DESNZ / Defra UK Government GHG Conversion Factors 2026, freighting goods, kg CO2e per tonne.km. Open Government Licence v3.0.
The rest of the life cycle
1 module beyond A1-A3 now carries a figure, and 5 still do not. Nothing here is added into the headline total above — each module is reported separately, because a figure over some modules is not comparable to one over others.
A5w Construction — material waste
Not statedA wastage rate is a property of the trade, the detailing and the site, not of the design — a default invented here would be the figure that reached a submission. State one and this is computed.
A5a Construction — site activities
Not statedSite plant, temporary works and welfare follow the contractor's programme rather than the design. At concept stage there is no programme, and estimating it from floor area would be a figure with no owner. It is the contractor's to supply, and a RICS or GLA submission expects it from them.
B1-B5 Replacement (B4 only)
From the library0 kg0.0 kgCO₂e/m² at the high end
Nothing in this schedule is replaced within 60 years — every counted class has a service life longer than the study period. That is a real zero for B4 and not a gap. Lengthen the period and it will stop being zero. B1, B2, B3 and B5 — use, maintenance, repair and refurbishment — are NOT included here and need a maintenance regime nobody has written at Stage 2.
A replacement bought decades from now is priced at TODAY'S A1-A3 figure, because a projected one would be this product's invention. Grids decarbonise and manufacturing improves, so this is very probably an over-statement — safe for a floor, and the unsafe direction in a retrofit-versus-rebuild comparison, where an inflated B4 is exactly what makes demolition look reasonable.
B6 Operational energy
Not statedAn energy model's output, not a material assessment's. Nothing here models the building's services, fabric performance or occupancy, and producing a figure would imply it had. The GLA and RICS both take it from the energy assessment submitted alongside.
C1-C4 End of life
Not statedEnd of life is a scenario rather than a property of the design, and the routes differ by orders of magnitude for some materials — timber to landfill against timber recycled is not a refinement, it is a different answer. Choose the route you are assuming.
D Beyond the boundary
Not statedReuse and recovery potential is reported separately from the total under EN 15804 and never netted into it. This product enforces that rule elsewhere and does not compute the module, because a Stage 2 design has not decided how anything is fixed together — and a module D credit is the figure most often quietly subtracted from a total it does not belong in.
Every figure, and the arithmetic behind it
2 of 8 lines carry arithmetic, and every one of them reproduces the figure the assessment reported — the steps below are recomputed and compared, not restated. The other 6 are held out of the total, and an excluded line has no arithmetic to show. This proves the working is what it says it is. It does not prove the figure is right: whether the band, the density or the class assignment suits your product is a separate argument, and each is named above so it can be had.
Run
117c2bf2-e8aabfeb
Quote this beside any figure taken from this assessment. The first half is your inputs and the second is the reference data they were priced against, so a figure that will not reproduce announces itself: the same inputs against revised data produce a different identifier, which is the warning a version number would have missed.
Substructure Reinforced concrete raft foundation
597 declarations890 m3 × 2,400 kg/m3 = 2,136,000 kg
Density supplied by you for Concrete, in-situ and precast in m3. No density is assumed by this product — a line without one is held out of the total instead.
2,136,000 kg × 0.0553 kgCO₂e/kg = 118,095 kgCO₂e
25th percentile of 597 published declarations in the mineral category (gwp_total). Not a figure for any product — the lower end of what the category actually declares.
2,136,000 kg × 0.101 kgCO₂e/kg = 215,059 kgCO₂e
75th percentile of the same 597 declarations.
Superstructure CLT frame and floor plates
Glulam, CLT and engineered timber stores biogenic carbon, and the benchmark for it covers A1-A3 only — the release that balances that storage falls in modules C3/C4, outside these figures. Netting it into a total compared against an A1-A5 target would credit storage the target does not anticipate, so it is reported separately below. Supply a whole-life figure for this line, or read the total as excluding it.
Superstructure Structural steel beams and columns
74 declarations410 t × 1,000 kg/t = 410,000 kg
The schedule states a mass directly; no density is involved.
410,000 kg × 1.661 kgCO₂e/kg = 680,985 kgCO₂e
25th percentile of 74 published declarations in the metals category (gwp_total). Not a figure for any product — the lower end of what the category actually declares.
410,000 kg × 4.675 kgCO₂e/kg = 1,916,926 kgCO₂e
75th percentile of the same 74 declarations.
Envelope Brick slip rainscreen on mineral wool
Supply kilograms per m2 for Clay brick and block — the benchmark is declared by mass and the schedule is not, so the two cannot be multiplied without it.
Envelope Aluminium curtain walling
Supply kilograms per m2 for Aluminium products — the benchmark is declared by mass and the schedule is not, so the two cannot be multiplied without it.
Envelope PIR insulation board to roof
Supply kilograms per m2 for PIR and PUR rigid foam — the benchmark is declared by mass and the schedule is not, so the two cannot be multiplied without it.
Internal finishes Plasterboard partitions on steel studs
Supply kilograms per m2 for Plasterboard and gypsum products — the benchmark is declared by mass and the schedule is not, so the two cannot be multiplied without it.
Fit-out Bespoke reception feature
Name a material class for this line — nothing in it was recognised.
What this figure can be submitted into
Of 9 UK carbon standards a specifier is likely to be asked about, 1 can be answered from a Stage 2 assessment as it stands and 4 ask for a wider boundary than it covers. The rest ask a different question or belong to a later stage of the project.
The same gap recurs, so it is stated once rather than on every row. Modules A4 and A5. Nearly every standard here writes its figure over A1-A5 while a Stage 2 assessment computes A1-A3, so the same two modules are missing each time. A4 needs a chosen supplier and therefore a distance; A5a follows the contractor's programme. Both stay open until the project has them, rather than being estimated from floor area — an estimate there would be a figure with no owner, and it would be the figure that closed the gap on paper.
RICS Whole Life Carbon Assessment
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors
Report the building against the full EN 15978 module ladder, stating what each module contains and what was excluded.
- Modules:
- A1-A3, A4, A5w, A5a, B1-B5, B6, B7, C1-C4, D
- Per:
- m² GIA
- Sign-off:
- Self-declared
This is the one standard whose structure the assessment already follows: it asks for a module statement rather than a single number, and the module table on the assessment IS that statement. One of the nine modules carries a figure.
Still needed: A4 needs a supplier and therefore a distance; A5w needs a wastage rate per class; the B and C modules need a study period and end-of-life routes. All of them are inputs an assessor states, not values this product can derive from a Stage 2 schedule.
GLA whole-life carbon assessment (referable applications)
Greater London Authority
Report embodied carbon over the A modules for a referable application, on the GLA's own template, alongside the energy assessment.
- Modules:
- A1-A3, A4, A5w, A5a
- Per:
- m² GIA
- Sign-off:
- Self-declared
One of the four A modules is computed. A figure covering A1-A3 quoted against a limit written over A1-A5 understates by roughly a third, and understates in the direction that passes.
Still needed: A4 and A5. A5a in particular follows the contractor's programme rather than the design, so no Stage 2 tool can supply it — the GLA expects it from the contractor.
NRM elemental reporting
RICS (New Rules of Measurement)
Report on the NRM group and sub-element structure, so carbon sits on the same breakdown as cost.
- Modules:
- A1-A3
- Per:
- m² GIA, by element
- Sign-off:
- —
NRM is a classification rather than a limit, so there is nothing to be in or out of scope OF. The assessment classifies schedule lines onto the NRM structure directly and carries the unallocated remainder as its own row.
UK Net Zero Carbon Buildings Standard — upfront carbon
UKNZCBS (cross-industry initiative)
Demonstrate upfront embodied carbon at or below the sector limit for the relevant year.
- Modules:
- A1-A3, A4, A5w, A5a
- Per:
- m² GIA
- Sign-off:
- Third-party verified
Upfront carbon is A1-A5 and this figure is A1-A3, so it cannot be tested against the limit — and a partial figure compared to a whole-figure limit fails in the direction that looks like a pass. The limit itself is not reproduced here: it is sector-specific, year-specific and revised, and a transcribed copy would be quoted back as verified.
Still needed: A4 and A5, plus the current limit for the sector and year, read from the Standard itself at the time of submission.
LETI / RIBA 2030 embodied-carbon bands
LETI; Royal Institute of British Architects
Place the design in a band from A++ to G against published band boundaries.
- Modules:
- A1-A3, A4, A5w, A5a
- Per:
- m² GIA
- Sign-off:
- Self-declared
The bands are defined over A1-A5. Banding an A1-A3 figure would move most designs up one or two letters, and a letter is precisely the output that gets carried into a planning statement without its scope attached.
Still needed: A4 and A5, and the band boundaries from the current publication. Both bodies revise them, and neither revision carries a commencement date this product could check against.
SCORS structural carbon rating
Institution of Structural Engineers
Rate the STRUCTURE on the SCORS scale, from the structural frame's carbon alone.
- Modules:
- A1-A3, A4, A5w
- Per:
- m² GIA, structure only
- Sign-off:
- Self-declared
SCORS is measured over the structure — substructure, frame, floors — and NOT over the whole building. A whole-building figure rated on the SCORS scale is not a poor SCORS rating; it is a different measurement wearing the same letter. The assessment can produce the structural subtotal, but the rating needs the scale, and the scale is the IStructE's to publish and revise.
Still needed: A4 and A5w for the structural lines, and the current SCORS scale. The IStructE publishes its tool openly, which is where the scale should be read from.
UKNZCBS 'On Track' check and as-built verification
UKNZCBS (cross-industry initiative)
Confirm at practical completion, using as-built data, that the building met the limits it was designed to, and assemble the evidence for a third-party verifier.
- Modules:
- A1-A3, A4, A5w, A5a
- Per:
- m² GIA
- Sign-off:
- Third-party verified
This is an as-built check and the assessment is a Stage 2 design estimate against material CLASSES, not products. The two are separated by every procurement decision on the project. A design-stage figure presented into an as-built verification is the substitution nobody catches, because the number is in the right box.
Still needed: Procured product EPDs, actual delivery distances, and the contractor's site records — none of which exists at concept stage.
Operational energy standards (Part L, UKNZCBS energy limits, EPC)
Various
Report the energy the building consumes in use.
- Modules:
- B6
- Per:
- kWh/m²/yr
- Sign-off:
- Third-party verified
An energy model's output, not a material assessment's. Nothing in this product models the building's services, its fabric performance or its occupancy, and combining a material figure with an energy one here would imply it had.
Still needed: An energy assessment, which is a separate discipline and a separate submission. This is listed so that its absence is explicit rather than assumed.
ConcreteZero / SteelZero member reporting
Climate Group
Report volumes of concrete and steel procured against a member commitment, in the initiative's own reporting format.
- Modules:
- not a module-based figure
- Per:
- tonnes or m³ procured
- Sign-off:
- Self-declared
A procurement return counted in material bought, not an assessment counted in carbon emitted. It is reported by the buying organisation across its portfolio and over a reporting year, neither of which is a property of one project's design.
Still needed: Procurement records across the member's portfolio. A design schedule is an intention to buy and not a record of having bought.
No limit or band is reproduced here. Not the UKNZCBS sector limits, not the LETI or RIBA 2030 band boundaries, not the SCORS scale. Each is revised by its publisher, none is legislation, and none carries a commencement date that could be checked — so a copy held here would be stated confidently and quoted back as verified. Read the value from the body that publishes and dates it, and use this to know whether your figure is in scope for it first.
Specification clauses for this schedule
A maximum GWP per material category, written as a clause you can paste into a specification. The limit comes from the category’s own published EPD distribution — not from an industry target — so the clause states its percentile and sample size and can be checked by whoever it binds.
A tighter limit is not automatically better. Below a certain point a carbon cap stops selecting on performance and starts selecting the firms that happen to have published — a sole-source specification written in carbon, discovered at tender. Each clause states how many declarations clear it, and a limit clearing too few is refused rather than printed.
Mineral building materials
p40 · ~239 of 597 declarations clear itMineral building materials — maximum global warming potential Products offered shall have a declared global warming potential (GWP-total, modules A1-A3) not exceeding 62.06 kg CO2e per tonne, evidenced by an Environmental Product Declaration to EN 15804+A2. Basis of the limit. The limit is the 40th percentile of 597 published declarations in this category, of which approximately 239 meet it. It is not taken from any industry target or published benchmark, and it is stated this way so that it can be checked and challenged. Status. This is a procurement requirement, not a statement of regulatory compliance. Meeting it does not demonstrate conformity with any standard, planning condition or building regulation. Currency of evidence. The declaration shall be valid at the date of supply, not at the date of tender. 43% of declarations in this category are already expired, so an EPD offered in support of a bid should be checked rather than assumed current. Unit of the limit. The limit is expressed by mass because that is the basis the underlying declarations normalise to. Around 64% of declarations in this category are published per unit volume rather than by mass. Where the specification measures this product in another unit, state the density used to convert and apply it consistently to every product offered. A density assumed here would be the one figure in this clause with no owner. Products without a declaration. Absence of an EPD is absence of evidence, not evidence of a higher figure. Where a product has no declaration, state that and price it; do not substitute a generic value and offer it as a declared one.
Metals
p40 · ~30 of 74 declarations clear itMetals — maximum global warming potential Products offered shall have a declared global warming potential (GWP-total, modules A1-A3) not exceeding 2.16 kg CO2e per kg, evidenced by an Environmental Product Declaration to EN 15804+A2. Basis of the limit. The limit is the 40th percentile of 74 published declarations in this category, of which approximately 30 meet it. It is not taken from any industry target or published benchmark, and it is stated this way so that it can be checked and challenged. Status. This is a procurement requirement, not a statement of regulatory compliance. Meeting it does not demonstrate conformity with any standard, planning condition or building regulation. Currency of evidence. The declaration shall be valid at the date of supply, not at the date of tender. 30% of declarations in this category are already expired, so an EPD offered in support of a bid should be checked rather than assumed current. Unit of the limit. The limit is expressed by mass because that is the basis the underlying declarations normalise to. Where the specification measures this product in another unit, state the density used to convert and apply it consistently to every product offered. A density assumed here would be the one figure in this clause with no owner. Products without a declaration. Absence of an EPD is absence of evidence, not evidence of a higher figure. Where a product has no declaration, state that and price it; do not substitute a generic value and offer it as a declared one.
No clause for these, and why
- Timber and wood-based — 37 declarations stand behind this category, under the 60 a percentile needs before it describes a market rather than a handful of specific products. Specify a named performance requirement from the manufacturers' own EPDs instead, where you can see whose they are.
- Insulation — 35 declarations stand behind this category, under the 60 a percentile needs before it describes a market rather than a handful of specific products. Specify a named performance requirement from the manufacturers' own EPDs instead, where you can see whose they are.
Already closed by regulation
This is a higher-risk building. A fire constraint found at Stage 4 is a redesign; the same constraint now is a choice.
- Glulam, CLT and engineered timber — Typically D. On a higher-risk building, external-wall materials must achieve A2-s1,d0 or better, so a product in this class will need to be evidenced above its class typical or the build-up will have to change. Cheaper to settle now than in technical design.
- PIR and PUR rigid foam — Typically E. On a higher-risk building, external-wall materials must achieve A2-s1,d0 or better, so a product in this class will need to be evidenced above its class typical or the build-up will have to change. Cheaper to settle now than in technical design.
What would narrow this, in the order that narrows it most
Ordered by the share of the uncounted schedule each answer brings in — by quantity, not by line count, so one envelope line outranks six of ironmongery.
- 39%Internal finishes Plasterboard partitions on steel studsSupply kilograms per m2 for Plasterboard and gypsum products — the benchmark is declared by mass and the schedule is not, so the two cannot be multiplied without it.
- 27%Envelope Brick slip rainscreen on mineral woolSupply kilograms per m2 for Clay brick and block — the benchmark is declared by mass and the schedule is not, so the two cannot be multiplied without it.
- 17%Envelope PIR insulation board to roofSupply kilograms per m2 for PIR and PUR rigid foam — the benchmark is declared by mass and the schedule is not, so the two cannot be multiplied without it.
- 11%Superstructure CLT frame and floor platesGlulam, CLT and engineered timber stores biogenic carbon, and the benchmark for it covers A1-A3 only — the release that balances that storage falls in modules C3/C4, outside these figures. Netting it into a total compared against an A1-A5 target would credit storage the target does not anticipate, so it is reported separately below. Supply a whole-life figure for this line, or read the total as excluding it.
- 6%Envelope Aluminium curtain wallingSupply kilograms per m2 for Aluminium products — the benchmark is declared by mass and the schedule is not, so the two cannot be multiplied without it.
- 0%Fit-out Bespoke reception featureName a material class for this line — nothing in it was recognised.
What this is
- — Ranges are the interquartile span of published EPDs for each material class, not a figure for any product. A class is what has been chosen at this stage; a product has not, and reporting a single number would be a median dressed as a result.
- — Class typicals are indicative. Reaction to fire is a TEST RESULT for a product in its end-use configuration, not a property of the substance. Facings, adhesives, cavities and fixings all change it — two boards from one factory can classify differently on their facing alone. This is what the class usually achieves and is not a classification: it cannot support a compliance claim or stand in for a test certificate.
- — The target's scope is "A1–A5, kgCO2e/m² GIA" — a figure computed over different modules is not comparable to it.
- — Ranges are computed over modules A1-A3 only, from Okobaudat EPDs. Where the target covers more, the omitted modules are all positive, so the figure is a floor and not an estimate of the target's quantity.
- — Not a compliance submission. Building Safety Act Gateway 2 is assembled at the end of Stage 4 from a technical design; this is the concept-stage statement that precedes it.
Run it on your own schedule
The signed-in product takes your schedule, keeps it against the project, and lets you close the asks one at a time — each one narrowing the range and raising the coverage until a verdict against the target is actually available.