CarbonSpec / Compare options
Compare design options
Steel against concrete against timber, or any two ways of describing the same building. Each schedule is run through the same parser and assessment the product uses, and the result is a band per option rather than a number.
Most of the time it will decline to pick a winner. At concept stage the band for a material class is routinely wider than the difference between two sensible designs, so the ranges overlap and no ordering is available from the data. That is the finding, and it is more useful than a false one: it means the choice should be made on programme, cost or buildability, and revisited when products are chosen rather than classes.
One option is established as lower
Option A — concrete frame is established as lower than Option B — steel frame: its whole range sits below, with 23 kgCO₂e/m² between them at the closest point. That holds at every percentile, so it does not depend on which end of either band turns out to be right.
Each option as a band
No midpoint is marked. A midpoint bar is how this comparison is usually got wrong: it asserts an ordering the assessment does not contain, and two options whose midpoints differ by 40% can have ranges overlapping over a third of their width.
- Option A — concrete frame41–75 kgCO₂e/m² · 67% covered
- Option B — steel frame97–260 kgCO₂e/m² · 67% covered
Axis runs from 0 to 273 kgCO₂e/m². Bands are the p25–p75 span of the material classes in each schedule, over module A1-A3 only.
What this cannot tell you
- Whether the structure works. Nothing here checks that a frame spans, carries or complies. Two schedules can describe buildings only one of which stands up, and this would compare them happily.
- Whether the quantities are right. A timber option with an under-measured frame wins on carbon for the same reason it would win on cost, and the coverage check catches missing lines rather than wrong numbers.
- Whether a timber option is being flattered by its own coverage. Add a CLT or glulam frame and the comparison will usually disqualify itself on coverage. That is not a bug: classes storing biogenic carbon are held out of the netted total, because summing them lets sequestration silently cancel emissions elsewhere in the schedule. The consequence is that a timber schedule counts less of itself, and an uncorrected comparison would hand it the win for that reason alone.
- Anything beyond A1-A3.Transport, construction waste, replacement over the study period and end of life are all absent, and they do not fall equally on every option — a timber frame’s end-of-life scenario matters more than a concrete one’s.